From Smart Meter rollout…to a moment of pride

The Badger’s been following progress of the UK’s Smart Meter rollout, a programme that’s missed every completion date so far, for some time. The rollout, which is paid for by consumers through their electricity bills, was originally due to complete in 2019. It now has a target to complete by 2030. Recent news about it and its current status, can be found here, here, and here. The rollout is an example of why it’s appropriate to be highly sceptical that any UK government energy programme will be on time and to budget. Whilst the rollout, the AI stock market correction, the hacking of French supermarket freezers, and the human frailties of Nvidia’s CEO, all triggered some Badger musings, it’s an unexpected personal moment of pride that is at the heart of what follows.

The Badger’s 6-year-old grandson excitedly announced last week that his Beaver Scout troop was taking part in the local Remembrance Sunday event and that he wanted the Badger to watch him in the associated parade. He knew it was an important event because the Beaver troop leader had asked the children to find out if any of their ancestors had served in the military during WW1 and WW2. On being asked that very question, the Badger sensitively told his grandson that their great-grandfathers, and great-great-grandfathers had all seen military service in the conflicts. They had all been very brave, they had all survived, and they all wanted future generations to remember that the freedom we cherish today is because of the sacrifice made by many. At that time, the Badger explained, they had no computers, no smartphones, no internet, no jet airliners, no robots, and no television. They fought for what they believed in, and they deserve our respect on every Remembrance Sunday. The Badger didn’t mention that one ancestor was awarded not one, but two Military Medals for bravery in France, another fought in North Africa, became a POW, and was on the ‘Long March to Freedom’ from camps in Germany, and another had been a first aider and stretcher-bearer.

On Remembrance Sunday, the Badger watched the parading Beaver troop approach his position in the crowds. They stopped for a minute adjacent to the Badger’s position, close enough to see his grandson turn to the youngster next to him who was engrossed on a smartphone, and hear his grandson say, ‘You should put that away and show some respect’. The troop leader gave him a thumbs-up and patted him on the head. The Badger experienced a moment of instant pride, and the youngster sheepishly put the smartphone in his pocket. Lest we forget, humans have existed for thousands of years without the internet, AI, and Smart Meters. The Badger thinks that if children knew more about their family ancestors, the sacrifices they made, and a life that isn’t digital-first, then perhaps the future will not be as bleak as it sometimes looks…

Has our dependence on the online world gone too far?

Having worked in IT for decades delivering systems for a range of clients, the Badger’s suspicious that rigour in AI development is lower than that demanded by his clients. Perhaps the Badger’s suspicion is unfounded, but one has to wonder when there’s regular news about AI agents escaping their creator’s clutches to do things they shouldn’t. AI might be catapulting us towards a very different future, but there’s a huge question mark over whether a) AI companies can be trusted to manage the risks associated with the technology effectively, and b) be held accountable for mistakes. ‘Trust us’ seems to be the refrain from these companies. Trust, however, must be earned and social media companies blew that over the last decade or so for many people. Albert Einstein’s quip ‘Whoever is careless with the truth in small matters cannot be trusted with important matters’ comes to mind. When high-risk industries from aviation to banking are, for the public good, subject to regulation, independent oversight, and meaningful penalties, then it cannot be acceptable that AI companies should be treated differently, especially when Anthropic warns of existential risks without safeguards.

More people today are wondering about the wisdom of depending on, and trusting, the online world in the light of the following. Meta’s $25 billion fine for misleading users on privacy. The State Attorney-General commented that ‘For too long, powerful technology companies have operated as though their size and influence put them above the law’, a sentiment shared by many. A PHP flaw has taken websites offline across the internet. The scramble to patch has disrupted organisations and users alike, and it’s highlighted once more our dependence on the internet and online services in daily life. Microsoft has pulled out of the project building the UK’s largest AI data centre due to power connection difficulties, a reminder that AI data centres are power-hungry, will only come on stream when their power demands are sustainably met, and do little for the planet. AI-related stocks have been highly volatile recently as investors increasingly question whether the huge investments being made are sustainable and will deliver profit. AI is now clearly impacting employment – see here, for example. Finally, the UK government wants everyone to improve their personal preparedness for emergencies and digital disruption is an item central to their messaging. Being able to function without access to online services is a no-brainer.

Has our dependence on the online world gone too far? Yes? Having lived without the internet, online services, and AI through the UK 3-day week energy crisis of the 1970s, the Badger knows that life can and will go on without them. Perhaps it’s time for younger generations to realise this, because, as sure as eggs are eggs, there will be serious, highly disruptive, AI and cyber-driven emergencies in the future which they will need to cope with…